CASE STUDY 路 BUSINESS
馃幃

Why Did Nokia N-Gage Fail?

A Game Console You Had to Hold Sideways to Call

2003YEAR
BUSINESSCAUSE
Hundreds of millions of development and marketing; roughly 3 million units in two years against tens of millions of Game BoysTHE BURN

What happened

Nokia owned 40% of the world's mobile market and decided phones should also be game consoles. The N-Gage made you hold it flat against your cheek to talk ('sidetalking'), swap games by removing the battery, and pay $299. Gamers mocked it, developers hedged, and the Game Boy Advance outsold it absurdly. Nokia killed it in 2006 - and the mockery followed the brand for years.

The fatal mistake

Designing around the company's asset (the phone) instead of the user's job (playing) - every compromise, from the battery-swapping game slots to the ear-cheek speaker, traced back to that one choice.

The lesson

A platform extension must be excellent at the NEW job first, or it is excellent at nothing. If the core competency forces the design, the product is a feature, not a category.

The antidote book

The Innovator's Dilemma cover
The Innovator's DilemmaClayton M. Christensen 路 Business & Startups 路 6 lessons

Great companies fail not despite good management but BECAUSE of it: listening to best customers blinds them to the disruption below.

READ THE SUMMARY OPEN INTERACTIVE BOOK
EXPLORE ALL 530 FAILURE CASE STUDIES

They paid full price. You get the lesson in simple English.